Tax disputes / challenging tax authority decisions
Tax disputes and challenges to Federal Tax Service decisions
A tax dispute before a Russian commercial court is a legal challenge to the authority's decision, evidence and procedure. The accounting position is only part of the case.
I handle challenges to Russian tax authority decisions, including additional assessments, VAT-deduction disputes and liability under Article 122 of the Russian Tax Code, as well as disputes involving Article 54.1 of the Russian Tax Code. Work includes administrative complaints to the higher tax authority and applications to a Russian commercial court under the applicable procedural rules Article 198 of the Russian Commercial Procedure Code, together with support during field and desk tax audits. Business fragmentation, business-purpose analysis and counterparty evidence are recurring issues, but the legal basis must be assessed in each case.
Initial assessment
When assistance may be needed and what the work can cover
IndicatorsSigns that the issue is already active
- the tax inspectorate has issued a decision imposing additional tax, denying a deduction or imposing liability
- the administrative-appeal deadline is approaching or may already have expired
- the assessment materially affects the company's working capital
- you need to determine the correct court filing, deadline and evidence
Work that may be requiredSteps that affect the position
- review of the tax decision: Tax Code basis, procedural compliance and evidential support
- assessment of the challenge: subject matter, deadlines, evidence and amount actually in dispute
- preparation of an administrative complaint and, where required, an application to a Russian commercial court under Article 138 of the Russian Tax Code
- representation through judgment, appeal and cassation where required
Tools
What may be used to defend the position
An evidence-based assessment of whether the assessment can be set aside or reduced, with the next procedural steps identified
Document-control framework
designed to reduce repeat tax risk in similar transactions
Common questions
Other questions commonly raised on this topic
What is Article 54.1 of the Russian Tax Code and how can it be applied against a taxpayer?
Article 54.1 of the Russian Tax Code is a central statutory provision in disputes over reductions of the tax base, VAT deductions and deductible expenses. It operates alongside, rather than as a simple replacement for, earlier case-law concepts associated with Resolution No. 53 of the Plenum of the Supreme Commercial Court of 12 October 2006.
The first part of Article 54.1 (Article 54.1(1) of the Russian Tax Code) addresses reduction of the tax base or tax payable through distortion of information about economic events or taxable objects. The second part (Article 54.1(2) of the Russian Tax Code) sets statutory conditions relevant to tax-base reductions and deductions. Their application is fact-specific; the use of subcontractors or third parties does not by itself justify an automatic conclusion without analysing the actual transaction, performance chain and the statutory test.
Evidence may include logistics, resources, personnel, business purpose, communications and the actual performers of the transaction. The Federal Tax Service letter of 10 March 2021 No. BV-4-7/3060@ is a non-normative methodological document that may be relevant to how the tax authority applies Article 54.1 of the Russian Tax Code; it does not replace the Tax Code or binding court law.
How to challenge a Federal Tax Service decision: procedure and deadlines
Challenging a tax decision generally requires attention to the administrative appeal procedure before court. An appeal against a decision that has not yet taken effect is filed within the statutory period provided by the Tax Code (Article 101(9) of the Russian Tax Code). The filing route, effect on entry into force and review period depend on the type of complaint and the applicable Tax Code provisions.
A complaint may also be available after the decision has taken effect, subject to its own statutory period. Court proceedings then follow the rules governing challenges to non-normative acts, including Articles 197–198 of the Russian Commercial Procedure Code. The court filing period and its starting point must be calculated from the particular procedural history, including completion of the mandatory administrative stage where it applies. A missed appeal deadline does not automatically mean every later remedy is lost; each remaining route and any restoration mechanism must be checked separately.
Need a position on the case?
Describe the matter on Telegram: the document received, its date, the amount at risk and what has already been sent to the other party or authority.
Initial contact
Describe the situation — I will start with the document and deadline
Describe what you received, the date, the amount at risk and what has already been submitted. The first practical step will be clear after review.
Materials on this issue